(Tcl) Socket Connect Failure Cases

Demonstrates a few common situations that would cause a TCP connect to a remote host:port to fail, an examines the LastErrorText for each case.

This example discusses the following cases:

1. The remote host is not listening on the desired port.
2. No remote host exists at the IP address (such as on a LAN).
3. The local Windows Firewall blocks the outbound connection.
4. Your ISP blocks the outbound connection.
5. The remote Windows Firewall blocks the inbound connection.
6. The domain cannot be resolved to an IP address.

Chilkat Tcl Extension Downloads Chilkat Tcl Extension Downloads

load ./chilkat.dll

# This example requires the Chilkat API to have been previously unlocked.
# See Global Unlock Sample for sample code.

set socket [new_CkSocket]

set tls 0
set maxWaitMillisec 5000

# First test the case where the remote host is not listening on the desired port.
# In this case, my LAN has a computer at 192.168.1.137, but nothing on that computer
# is listening for inbound connection to port 6660.
set success [CkSocket_Connect $socket "192.168.1.137" 6660 $tls $maxWaitMillisec]
puts [CkSocket_lastErrorText $socket]

# The call to Connect should fail quickly, and the LastErrorText will contain
# a message about the connection being rejected:
# 
#      socket2Connect:
#        connect2:
#          ConnectFailReason: Connection rejected
#        --connect2
#      --socket2Connect

# Now test the case where there is no computer on the network at the desired IP address.
# For example, on my LAN, there is no computer at 192.168.1.188.  If ping is used to test,
# the error message would be "Destination host unreachable".

set success [CkSocket_Connect $socket "192.168.1.188" 80 $tls $maxWaitMillisec]
puts [CkSocket_lastErrorText $socket]

# In this case, the connection is "rejected" as before, but the connect hangs for the entire
# maximum waiting period (maxWaitMillisec), which is 5 seconds in this case.
# (If the maxWaitMillisec is a large enough amount of time, the operating system
# may fail the connect with a "connection rejected" after a long wait. 
# The difference is that when the remote host exists and is reachable, the failure is quick.)
# The portion of the LastErrorText for this failure is shown here:

#    connectInner:
#      hostname: 192.168.1.188
#      port: 80
#      tls: 0
#      maxWaitMs: 5000
#      socket2Connect:
#        connect2:
#          connectSocket:
#            connect_ipv6_or_ipv4:
#              timeout waiting for connect to complete
#              numSec: 5
#              numMicroSec: 0
#              failedWaitToConnect: Socket operation timeout.
#            --connect_ipv6_or_ipv4
#          --connectSocket
#          ConnectFailReason: Timeout
#        --connect2
#      --socket2Connect
#      Failed.
#    --connectInner

# Imagine that a new rule is added to Windows Firewall to block all connections
# for this example app.  The characteristics of the failure are the same as for
# the case where nothing on the remote computer is listening at the given port.
# The connection attempt fails immediately, and the error message (from the OS) is
# "connection rejected".  Also notice that SSL/TLS never enters the equation because
# the SSL/TLS handshake begins *after* the TCP connection is completed.  When the 
# TCP connection fails, it never reaches the point of even beginning the SSL/TLS negotiation.
set tls 1
set success [CkSocket_Connect $socket "192.168.1.188" 80 $tls $maxWaitMillisec]
puts [CkSocket_lastErrorText $socket]

#    connectInner:
#      hostname: smtp.gmail.com
#      port: 465
#      tls: 1
#      maxWaitMs: 5000
#      socket2Connect:
#        connect2:
#          ConnectFailReason: Connection rejected
#        --connect2
#      --socket2Connect
#      Failed.
#    --connectInner

# What about the case where the ISP blocks an outbound connection?  My home ISP is 
# Comcast cable, and they block outbound SMTP port 25.  
set tls 0
set success [CkSocket_Connect $socket "pop3.btconnect.com" 25 $tls $maxWaitMillisec]
puts [CkSocket_lastErrorText $socket]

# The result is a timeout:
#    connectInner:
#      hostname: pop3.btconnect.com
#      port: 25
#      tls: 0
#      maxWaitMs: 5000
#      socket2Connect:
#        connect2:
#          connectSocket:
#            connect_ipv6_or_ipv4:
#              timeout waiting for connect to complete
#              numSec: 5
#              numMicroSec: 0
#              failedWaitToConnect: Socket operation timeout.
#            --connect_ipv6_or_ipv4
#          --connectSocket
#          ConnectFailReason: Timeout
#        --connect2
#      --socket2Connect
#      Failed.
#    --connectInner

# What about the case where the Windows Firewall at the remote host is blocking the
# inbound connection.  On Chilkat's internal LAN, there is a computer at 192.168.1.127
# running an SSH server.  After adding an inbound rule to block port 22, external connections
# fail with a timeout, as shown below:

set success [CkSocket_Connect $socket "192.168.1.127" 22 $tls $maxWaitMillisec]
puts [CkSocket_lastErrorText $socket]

#    connectInner:
#      hostname: 192.168.1.127
#      port: 22
#      tls: 0
#      maxWaitMs: 5000
#      socket2Connect:
#        connect2:
#          connectSocket:
#            connect_ipv6_or_ipv4:
#              timeout waiting for connect to complete
#              numSec: 5
#              numMicroSec: 0
#              failedWaitToConnect: Socket operation timeout.
#            --connect_ipv6_or_ipv4
#          --connectSocket
#          ConnectFailReason: Timeout
#        --connect2
#      --socket2Connect
#      Failed.
#    --connectInner

# Finally, what if we try to connect to a hostname that does not resolve to an IP address?

set success [CkSocket_Connect $socket "www.thisdoesnotresolvetoanyipaddressxyz.com" 22 $tls $maxWaitMillisec]
puts [CkSocket_lastErrorText $socket]

# In this case there is an immediate failure:
#    connectInner:
#      hostname: www.thisdoesnotresolvetoanyipaddressxyz.com
#      port: 22
#      tls: 0
#      maxWaitMs: 5000
#      socket2Connect:
#        connect2:
#          connectSocket:
#            connect_ipv6_or_ipv4:
#              resolveHostname6:
#                getAddressInfo:
#                  Failed to get host address info. (3)
#                  SocketError: WSAHOST_NOT_FOUND No such host is known.
#                  hostOrIpAddr: www.thisdoesnotresolvetoanyipaddressxyz.com
#                  port: 22
#                  Versions of Windows earlier than Windows XP are limited to handling IPv4 only
#                  On Windows Server 2003 and Windows XP, IPv6 addresses are returned only if IPv6 is installed on the local computer.
#                --getAddressInfo
#              --resolveHostname6
#              Domain to IP address resolution failed.
#            --connect_ipv6_or_ipv4
#          --connectSocket
#          ConnectFailReason: DNS lookup failed
#        --connect2
#      --socket2Connect
#      Failed.
#    --connectInne

delete_CkSocket $socket